Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sean Prophet's avatar

Climate clearly bears many similarities to pandemics in the sense that it impacts everyone's lives while the response varies widely. In the past I've always tended to separate the physical impacts from the psychological responses. But it's becoming clear to me now that with any public health or environmental crisis, many human beings respond in ways that compound the crisis.

One primary response is rumor-mongering. Both climate and pandemics are existential threats. And various forms of denial tend to provide temporary relief. They allow people to try to continue to conduct business as usual. The other thing that happens is that sometimes there's an overcompensation in the opposite direction. For example, during covid, various religious groups deliberately held services with unmasked people which became super spreader events. With the climate, some people respond with conspicuous consumption "proving" that things are still normal and there's no crisis.

In both cases, there tends to be immediate feedback. With pandemics, people die. With climate, the loop is longer, but a cooler climate remains in living memory. Coal rolling trucks coexist with wildfire smoke resulting from conditions brought about by earlier emissions.

Both responses tend to create a false sense of invulnerability and a temporary feeling of control over forces much larger than humans. Vaccine and EV refusals occupy the same psychological space. "No one tells me what to do." It's very funny because some of the people most invested in denial are the most obedient to both human and divine authority figures. It's an abstraction mismatch. They comply with personal authority, but refuse to acknowledge physical systemic authority.

This also tracks with what I've referred to as dilution of empathy. People get very concerned about a single high-profile case like the shooting of an innocent person by authorities. But they seem oblivious when it comes to the regular grinding deaths from poverty and hunger among children.

It's all predictable primate behavior for a species that evolved for life in small groups rather than a global civilization. The same mechanics that make us hostile to out groups also make us hostile to mentally engaging with large unseen forces far outside the village.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?